Years with Mets: 1992-1995, 1999
Probably the most overpriced mustache to ever suit up for the Mets, Bobby Bonilla wasn't really all that terrible. He had 2-3 completely respectable seasons for the Metropolitans in the early 90s. The problem was that we paid approximately $3 billion (adjusted to 2008 dollars) for his services. And we brought him back for 60 games in 1999...?